Lunch Sack Gift Bags

I made 2 lunch sack gift bags. I'm planning on making one of them for this weekends stamp club. I'm not really sure which one I like best.... Take a look and let me know what you think. The design is similar, but the style of bag is different.
The above gift bags, shows more of the lunch sack. When I asked for my husbands opinion, he said it looked like a lunch bag, but just decorated...
He preferred this one. I would love to hear some of your feedback! Thank you and "Stamp Happy"!